HMD Skyline

In the wake of the FairPhone, HMD have come along with a similar scheme to enable users of their Skyline phone to repair it themselves when components break, wear out or go wrong. This is laudable on an eco-friendly basis, undoubtedly, as more OEMs take looking after the planet seriously, from packaging, boxes, distribution and more. But it's also got to be a contender as a phone - and worth considering for the shortlist along other devices, especially similarly-priced. I hope to see here if HMD have cracked the equation.

The box doesn't have a power charger in it, for 'tis the trend, you know, more eco-claims, but it is colour-coordinated with the shade of the device. (Maybe there was a charger supplied in some regions.) Presumably those with the 'twisted black' colour got a black box! This Neon Pink is much more preferable, though I guess your average Exec. wouldn't think so in their Boardroom! There is a colour-matched USB-C to USB-C cable, however, which is cute, and a SIM Card Tray tool.

The phone itself bears a clear resemblance to various of the Nokia phones from the past, particularly those Lumia ones - and especially (and spookily) the MeeGo-running N9 of 2011. It's not made of the same polycarbonate (which was lovely) and certainly not the dinky little size in the hand of pocket. The Skyline is big, feeling heavy (at 209.5g), clunky, hefty and lumpish. But that N9 design is lovely - and part of that heft is likely to do with getting the back off, which you had no chance of doing with the N9. But beware, the Skyline is not small! But it is beautifully made.

The sides being ‘rounded’ is nice (very comfortable to hold - though very slippery) but the corners being so sharp is just styling (like the N9) and not needed - they dig into one’s palms. Especially as this phone is that much bigger. The N9 got away with that one, being so small and poly, not metal, as here. But then most phones, 13 years on, are big! The size here is 159.8mm x 76mm x 8.9mm and compares decently closely, in this respect, to my Motorola Edge 50 Pro. It's just that the latter is more 'screen' than 'corner-styling'!

The 6.55", 1080p, 20:9, 402ppi P-OLED screen has a thick bezel all around and very rounded corners (obviously not in keeping with the corners of the device) as style again. The screen is nice and bright, peaking at 1000nits - well, until I put it alongside a Motorola - then it doesn't look so bright and suffers with mushy colours and muted tones - but away from that, it looks just fine. Most people won't be comparing phones next to each other, so won't be disappointed - I'm being picky! You can also use a slider in settings to adjust the White Balance, which is a nice (if basic compared to many others) option. It has a 144Hz refresh rate which can be set to that all the time, 120Hz all the time, 60Hz all the time or to Adaptive, making its mind up for itself, up to 120Hz. It all looks perfectly smooth to me, however its set - by then my eyes aren't 18 years old!

The Gorilla Glass 3 protected (all-but) front panel eases - and very, very slightly curves - into the aluminium of the frame on all four sides and looks/feels premium. There's a selfie punch-hole up-top and centre, which is not too intrusive, under the earpiece/second of the stereo speakers. Around the phone's aluminium perimeter there are aerial cutouts of course and microphones. On the bottom, there's the other of the stereo speaker pair, USB-C port, SIM Card/microSD Card Tray and a T4 Torx screw to get the glass back off (which I'll come to). There's an IP5/4 rating for the phone, so not the best (presumably because of taking it apart) but certainly good enough for light splashing and a bit of dust!

Taking the back off the phone is not trivial. Once the Torx screw is out (for which the user will need a driver which most households are unlikely to have, I contend), using a plectrum (or similar) one needs to slide it along in the gap 'popping' it out/off as it goes along. Always remembering that it's glass of course and could break - eventually bit by bit, it pops off. Putting it back is nearly as hairy as it needs pressure applied to 'pop' it back into the various housing points. Well, I didn't break it - but couldn't help thinking that it might have been better if was plastic! HMD will sell you an iFixit kit for £90 which gives you more tools than a plectrum that you might have hanging around - which would certainly make the job easier.

Anyway, once off, the repairability kicks into the agenda and HMD will then sell you a SIM Card Tray for £14, loudspeaker for £14, back cover (for those who break it getting it off!) for £28, charging port for £19, battery for £23 and some adhesive (in order to tackle the battery). In order to get the components out and new ones in, there's more tiny screws. Here's a link to a YouTube video by HMD showing how you do all this. The whole thing feels very much less of a user-accessible route than the FairPhone for example, but rather one that most people might want someone else to do this stuff for them! But kudos to HMD - at least there are options - you can get it apart and get the spare parts to repair it. Even if someone needs to help you. It's back together again now. Phew!

So that's all good then, a step in the right direction to keep phones lasting longer and out of landfill - except, hang on - HMD are only offering 2 Android OS updates to buyers! It arrives on Android 14 and will get 15 and 16. So, last update sometime following Google's release in the autumn of 2025, which isn't really very far away. And yet the phone is geared up with repairability like it's going to be around for a long time to be repaired when needed. Feels like it doesn't quite match up somehow - and arguably at odds with the philosophy. They are also only promising Google Security patches until July 2027, 3 years from release. I guess that part of this reflects a lot of phone here (which I'll come to) for the (now) £349 but something feels a bit skewed. Anyway, for the moment, it's pretty well up to date as I write in October 2024, as it has September's patches. Make sure that you update it as soon as you can because I did find plenty of bugs before this was done, which HMD have now largely fixed.

Under the hood it's equipped with the Snapdragon 7s Gen 2 (4nm) which feels perfectly adequate here in testing, copying large amounts of data from a PC, for example, initial setup as it's bombarded with all sorts of tasks like installing over 100 apps, sorting out updates, setting up the system. Prior to this September update, some of this was making the phone very hot by the way, but now, not. I've tried some car-racing tasks for gaming and again, now, it breezes through them without a judder. I'm not a heavy gamer so do check other reviewers' experiences on YouTube, but I'm guessing that if you're really into gaming in a big way you're much more likely to have a beefier, more expensive gaming phone anyway. There's 8GB RAM onboard which can be 'extended' making use of some of the storage by up to 8GB, with a restart of the system. However, we have found that this option is not particularly worth doing - 8GB RAM is really plenty for today's Android, proven by the fact that I have not noticed here, even with heavy multi-tasking, any problematic app shut-downs. Applications and services sit happily in RAM from way back!

The storage on this phone is 256GB, but there's also a 12GB RAM version and a 128GB/8GB RAM one out there, too. The storage is to some degree a moot point, however, as on the flip side of the nanoSIM Card tray there's an option for those who only want to use one SIM Card, to put a microSD Card in as portable storage (or to extend the internal). I have a 1TB card in there with tons of data on it and it's reading/writing perfectly well, no lag in evidence at all. HMD seem to be saying that it's only supported up to 512GB but not here - 1TB is fine - and no, I didn't format the card in the phone. Nice to see the Memory Card surviving in certain quarters of the Android world. This unit does have dual-SIM support (in place of that microSD Card side of the tray) and also for eSIM, but check for your regional variations.

The stereo speakers are very loud. Furthermore, there's an OZO Boost available if you fancy the challenge! This hikes up the volume up, if you have the setting turned on in Audio Settings, past 100% with a second press on the volume-up key. It then gets even louder! However, in my tests here, it becomes, with most music files and services I've tried, pretty much unusable when engaged. System sounds seem to make decent use of the function as ringtones and notifications are very loud, but for media playback, music and video, it's blowing the bass out when in use and top-end frequencies are made even more shrill than when dialling it back down a bit.

It's a shame there's no built-in equaliser here - no Dolby Atmos for example - but I have found that if you turn off the OZO boost, put it on 100%, then engage our oft' referred to super audio app Wavelet, you get the best reproduction possible from the hardware. A slight payoff on volume in the process but the phone has enough to compensate as it's so loud to start with. Your mileage may vary of course, depending on music genre, file encoding or service accessed, but this what I have found. The stereo effect is decently pronounced even holding the phone as far away from the face as 2 feet. Using test video from YouTube which also play around with audio and soundstage, the phone does indeed throw the audio around making good use of its speakers. No complaints.

There's no 3.5mm ear/headphone audio socket (which would have really then felt like a Lumia/Nokia) but USB-C out (with and adapter for legacy or as-is for newer gear) works just fine and actually sounds loud and with good quality. All these tests are clearly based on using specific equipment, so again, test with yours if you can first. I'm using a pair of Google's own wired USB-C earphones for this first test. Incidentally, the OZO Boost doesn't work with ear/headphones - for obvious reasons! Second test is with a pair of Fiio FF1 Beryllium wired earbuds and 'dumb' 3.5mm-USB-C adapter, which makes the sound even louder and even better! Replacing the 'dumb' adapter with a DAC-enabled Razer one and, as you might expect, the test is then more about the adapter than the phone - and yes, it blows to ears away for volume (and quality). So plenty of options, even without that legacy port! Stereo separation is great again, soundstage present, depending again on source. Testing here with YouTube video and music. Really no complaints about audio reproduction for all-but audiophiles. Bluetooth (v5.2) sound, as you again would expect these days, is just excellent - again depending on attached gear. Testing here with a Sony WH-1000XM4 (with LDAC support) unit and also various buds. I can't see how anyone could complain about the output if this is their chosen route.

The phone has a 4,600mAh battery inside which can be charged at 33W with a wire or at 15W using wireless and the world's first (as far as I know) phone that supports the Qi2 standard, so kudos to HMD for getting in on that ahead of others! This emulates to a large degree what Apple have been doing with magnets, so that the phone can 'find' accessory charging devices quickly and lock into place without effort. Personally, I can't see the point really (except for maybe in-car on the dashboard) as I've never had any problems with Qi coils finding devices. Well, until now!

Ironically, I've had much trouble with this phone sitting it on bedside/desktop cradles. You know, the ones that sit-up and look at you (so that you can, for example, use the phone as a clock). I have four different models here which all work perfectly well with every other Android phone I've ever tried on them - and I've reviewed hundreds of phones - but here, all four of them fail to find the coil on this phone. From the image (above) you can see that coil appears to be in a decent enough central place, but clearly it's not. I have to place something under the phone, about 1cm high, for it to work (or turn it sideways and find the spot). Which is nuts - if this then renders every Qi charger stand out there produced for decades now, defunct! Lay it down flat on a charger and it's fine - and the charging works fine - so I guess that the coil in this phone is exceptionally 'low' in the back. Maybe that's something to do with repairability too. Still, at least it has Qi charging at this price-point, which many don't, and Qi2 it is, too! In addition to this, again, good at this price-point, the phone has Reverse Qi, which it executes at 5W - so top-ups for your earbuds or friend's phone!

Anyway, back to the battery and in my tests here I find that it takes about half an hour to half fill the battery from empty and almost an hour and a half for a full charge. This perfectly workable for most people, I think, even though a long way from, for example, the amazing speed Moto's 125W will do it. My 10% Reading Test returned a respectable enough 110 minutes and for most people, using the phone moderately, they'll just about get to lunchtime of Day 2 if pushed - at least it does for me and my average use. As always, it depends so much on what you're doing with your phone, so I quote here in my reviews based on the level playing field of my usage. Might not be much use to you, but if you read enough of my reviews you'll get the picture. Clinical it might not be, but hopefully you'll find the benchmark useful. Best idea is to charge at night. On a Qi stand. If you can find one that works!

Connectivity seems decent enough. I've tested all the usual elements and find that Bluetooth range is decent, WiFi 6e (if you can get it) is good and strong, tested here with 3 different networks, GPS for mapping and other dependencies seems good for locking on and holding on, NFC I have tested in local shops to pay and it seems to find the spot very quickly and the 5G cellular (I have a very good EE network here) processes data nicely, reliably and without fuss. I did have a bit of trouble with phone calls where the person the other end had trouble hearing me and vice-versa, but these tests are always network-dependent for both parties on multiple networks, so I'm not concerned about those blips. Repeat testing with other people/networks and things seem to be fine. You can also switch to WiFi calling if you prefer.

Along with the September Update and bug-fixes came one new feature, emulating others from various OEMs, that being what they're calling Detox Mode. It's actually very nicely implemented with a pleasant front-end and gives the user the options to control how much their apps and notifications can alert them. Chilling out away from social media and irritating calls/messages! It shows up as a (self-removing) widget if you place it on the homescreen and selecting it gives you plenty of options to customise how long you want to be left in peace for, who or what is allowed to get through the barrier, whether or not you want it on until you turn it off (soft, for quick breaks) or on until you reboot the phone (hard) and even change the wallpaper to a gently, calming image. It's not unique as I say, as others are doing it, but I do think that has been well thought out and is clear, easy to understand as well as useful for those who want/need it.

Security options are plentiful too, with a very nicely functioning Face Unlock which is quick and easy to set up, capacitive fingerprint scanner which works perfectly to get in, within the side-mounted power button which is just under the volume rocker on the left, the usual PIN/Pattern options, lift-to-wake, now Google's Theft Protection, Play Protection and Find My Device as well as (what I thought was Moto's) PIN Pad Scramble. So if you use PIN for opening up the phone, the system scrambles the numbers each time so that if someone's looking over your shoulder it's harder for them to clock your code. My only complaint in amongst all this is that there's no option on the power button to force the user to 'press' the power button to acknowledge the fingerprint, only 'touch', so accidental touches are frequent any annoying. Hopefully HMD will add that in an update soon.

Setting the phone up using Google's Backup and Restore using another phone was great. It gets better and better, but even for someone not using that tool, the process here is clear and straightforward. I guess it's not surprising that HMD are going to do some software-inclusion deals when pushing out hardware at this price and sure enough the usual bloaty offenders are present, booking dot com, LinkedIn, FaceBook and Kindred (whatever that is). All four, fortunately, are uninstallable. In fact the only one I found that wasn't was the now-lingering Meet from Google, which, as a standalone app, is now defunct. Still, at this price, for this hardware, we'll forgive them (in a way we won't with Sony, for example, doing similar and still charging £1200 for the phone)!

The homescreen layout is all-but (what we used to call) stock Android. But not quite. The At A Glance which Pixels have baked into the top of the screen is not there, though there is an option to add it as a widget, but the Google Search Bar at the foot of the screen is unremovable, just like Pixel. The only way to get round this one is to install another launcher, I guess - which would be a shame because otherwise it's nice here. Very much like the Nokia is, in fact, on, for example, the XR20, but modernised and with added benefits. It's also ported the Nokia's Always on Display which again, at this place in the market is a real bonus and unexpected.

The Always on Display shows the clock, day, date, weather, Notification (by icon only), charging status at the bottom and the artist name of any playing music under the date. Before the September update the track title was also present on the AoD, but they both seem to now be AWOL. The clock is fixed, big and bold, digital, 24 hour, but does suffer from the same auto-brightness issue that most Android phones do - it just gets the algorithm wrong and sometimes, in some lighting, it can't be seen. Typically, subdued lighting. Turning off Adaptive Brightness system-wide helps, but then most users won't want that off all the time and have adjust manually. Samsung seem to be the only OEM that has this sorted (and even then, via a Good Lock Module) but hopefully more will realise that it's not good and doesn't do the job well enough. Maybe HMD will be first to fix this, too, in a coming update.

HMD provide a bunch of their own widgets. Twenty four of them, actually! They have a Nothing Phone kind of feel about them, all black/white (though not pixelated)! A ton of clock and Weather options, Media controllers (the bigger ones even showing AlbumArt - take note, Sony) and Quick Settings too. The Quick Settings ones mostly create what look like folders on the homescreen with assignable shortcuts to various Settings you choose, from whatever you have in the top pull-down Notification shade. A shortcut of shortcuts, then! Talking of Settings, I note, as an aside, that the screen timeout doesn't support the 30-minute option, like Pixels do, but is rather capped at 10-minutes, like Samsung and certainly not the 'no limit' of TCL. I did hope that HMD were going to fix this in the September update so it was back to the usual 30-minutes, but not yet.

The Custom Button on the left of the phone can be, like the Nokia XR20's red button, assigned to a whole bunch of settings, functions or apps. A long-press for something, a double press for something else and a single press for settings. It's flush with the side of the phone and slightly knurled on the surface. I have it assigned to play/pause media on the long-press and torch on double-press. When you're done on the left, you can, using the same UI switch to the power button on the right and assign what you like to a double-press. I have Google Wallet on that for convenience in shops, but the options to customise/assign what you like to both these buttons are only limited to what you have installed - and HMD's core functions. It's a great addition to the hardware and genuinely useful for quick-access. This was something else that HMD bug-fixed as before the September update, use of this left button often froze the phone up and needed rebooting to get back to normal. So again, good for them for attending to this stuff.

The main camera on the back of the phone is surprisingly a 108MP f1.8 unit with OIS. The user can force the phone to use all those pixels but by default resulting photos are 'pixel binned' down to 12MP. The results from this are pleasing to me with nice colours, good detail and will be absolutely perfect for the target users. They will be equally pleased with the ability to shoot with the 2x optical zoom from the secondary 50MP f2 camera to get closer in on the subject. There's a 13MP wide-angle lens, thirdly, again providing the user with another option to open up and get more into the frame, though there's no AF for really, really close shots. The camera app is decent and simple enough compared to many - and even has a handheld Astro mode built in! In low light, the 'night' mode copes well enough creating images from situations all-but invisible to the human eye, portrait mode does a good job isolating subjects and creating shallow depth of field for bokeh, there's a Pro mode for fine control and a bunch of other modes to play with. Video can be shot at 4K@30fps, there's a very nicely-performing 50MP Selfie which will also shoot video at 1080p@30fps.

Impressively the camera software in the HMD skyline has focus peaking - something which you normally only find on higher end phones and cameras. This means that when the camera is viewing something, the exact items in the shot which were at the same focal distance (and specifically in focus) are highlighted in an extra colour so you can see at a glance whether thing you are trying to photograph is perfectly in focus or not. Nice touch. Thanks to Steve Litchfield my co-host on the Phones Show Chat weekly Podcast for explaining that and posting a couple of YouTube Shorts about this HMD Skyline which I'll link to here. HMD Skyline - Speakers, Custom Button and Focus Peaking and HMD Skyline - Self-Repair and Qi2. Furthermore, for a deep-dive on the HMD Camera with analysis and tons of samples, I'm going to do my usual trick and point you to our friends over at GSMArena and their coverage which starts here. Please do visit and support them as they do really useful work.

I forgot to mention that the vibration motor is wild! HMD should implement Sony's Dynamic Vibration with the Skyline as it would be a complete winner! I remember that the Nokia XR20's motor was similarly strong and loud, so maybe it's the same component.

In summary I'd say that this is a lovely handset. It's really nicely designed and with a premium-feeling fit'n'finish. The value-for-money equation is just about as it should be given what's on offer here, not silly expensive for the sake of the market, not cheaper than it should be to push sales. It has some really interesting features, ideas and a great nostalgia feel about it. It's big enough for those who like their phones big these days, has innovative Qi2, regardless of my complaint about older cradles, a nice-enough OLED panel, very loud speakers, custom-buttons, microSD support, good onboard storage too, a perfectly adequate chipset, RAM and good biometrics. The pearl here though for them is the repairability - if only they would match that ethos with the length of support on offer with OS and security updates. There are still bugs to fix, but certainly that September update was an encouraging and far-reaching resolution for many more before it. As always there's room for improvement but generally this is a good job at, now £349, a great price. Highly recommended.

Don't Move (2024)

Just a quick one about this decent-enough little thriller, now on Netflix. Kelsey Asbille (who played the fruit-loop cowgirl in Fargo 4) played it pretty well, though didn't have a lot to say as she was drugged for most of it!

It was quite tense in places with some situational atmosphere created nicely, as we get alongside our grieving girl, reflecting on life whilst fending off the serial killer, played by Finn Wittrock having fun!

It's kinda predictable in some ways and a bit unbelievable in others, so plot holes and handy co-incidences all-round! But the ticking time-bomb makes for a bit of a suspenseful thrill-ride and there's a few nicely staged gory scenes thrown in for good measure. There's some lovely scenery to look at and it's nicely shot. Certainly worth a look.

Fremont (2023)

This is a delightful little film about Donya who has left her family, life and friends behind in Afghanistan to legitimately go to the USA as an interpreter working with the American Army on one of the last of the flights out of Kabul when they withdrew from the country.

Her job as interpreter is now done and dusted and we join the story later on, as she leads a dull and uneventful life in Fremont within a small community of other people from Afghanistan. She goes to work for a Chinese family who make Fortune Cookies and ends up writing the 'fortunes' that go inside them.

Suddenly deciding that life is far too dull, she grabs the opportunity she has at work to put an appeal into one of the cookies to see if she could get a response from someone and hook up for love, encouraged by her very funny work colleague. A bit of a long-shot, but she gets a result of sorts and starts down the road of livening things up for herself.

While she reflects on her life, much of it is about the guilt of having left her family behind in Afghanistan, certainly her loneliness in the foreign land and more. She eventually opens up about this to a psychiatrist, who she goes to, to get sleeping pills. He wants to make her work hard for them by talking about her frustrations and life.

Unknown Anaita Wali Zada plays Donya beautifully well, reserved, quiet, shy, unconfident as she starts to find her wings. Gregg Turkington, who is apparently an Australian comedian, plays the medic very nicely - and much humour is injected into the storyline and character delivery and development.

It's clearly an arthouse piece, shot in black and white, in 4:3, and reminded me in style of Cuarón's Roma. It's beautifully imagined and directed by Babak Jalali, the performances are super and it's well worth a watch while it's doing the rounds just now on various streaming platforms. Charming, classy and fun.

The Silenced (2015)

I had a bit of a job tracking this one down but did in the end on the DailyMotion website - and it comes and goes on Mubi and other streaming services, some with adverts. It's a Korean film set in Korea in 1938 at an establishment which is half girls boarding school, half sanitorium. It reminds me very much in tone of the film I reviewed a week or two back called Level 16.

We follow the path of Joo-ran/Shizuko, who is a sick girl shipped into the institution as she appears to maybe have TB. She coughs up blood a lot, anyway! She soon finds out that there was a girl there before her called Shizuko which is why, I think, they have dubbed her that. The first Shizuko disappeared one day without even a goodbye to the rest of the girls, who all appear to be about 15 or 16. Then, as she's settling in and people are getting to know her, another girl disappears during the night - the nasty headmistress tells the girls that her parents took her away. All very shady and like in Level 16, our central character is keen to find out what's going on with this place and why girls disappear, assuming she's probably next!

The girls are all told that when they get better, if they take their 'medicine' and injections (like Level 16's vitamins) they would get 'taken to Tokyo in Japan'. The Japanese military are kind of in attendance and clearly have something to do with it, being just before WWII and when Korea was colonised by Japan. It's apparently not a true story, nor based on anything factual.

Anything more regarding the plot would be a bit of a giveaway so I'll leave it there and fill you in with some other stuff. Like it's a bit gory in places, turns from mystery to sinister thriller/horror eventually and has a few surprises up its sleeve - the main one being the big reveal as to what it's all about. Again, very Level 16.

There's quite a bit of atmosphere in places, the tone and themes are very dark, obviously, and although not really scary in any way, it's certainly an unsettling watch. I don't know the director Lee Hae-young nor any of the actors, but certainly the two or three girls in the lead roles do a decent enough job in having the audience convinced. A decent enough little thriller if you can track it down.

Motorola's Smart Connect (formerly Ready For)

I'm all Moto’d up again with the Motorola Edge 50 Pro! I sold my own Edge 50 Pro this week to try and recoup some overspent funds(!) and so have set up the MotoPR one! It really is a gorgeous phone with amazing capabilities. I’ve been trying to use it with no case at all, just to feel the lovely shape, curves, dinky size (without a case at least), screen edges, vegan eco whatsit back - it really is nice.

After the Motorola Razr 50 Ultra and Motorola Edge 50 Neo phones, the only bummer is no ‘proper’ Always on Display! Oh well, I survived without it with Moto for the last decade! But the reason I’m here with this today is that I was using Smart Connect (formerly Ready For) with a vengeance and thought I’d share thoughts. Sat in front of my PC, I don’t need to touch the phone, for anything! The features are...

Phone on PC is just perfect with pass-through audio (making great use of my Marshall Acton III of course!), video and virtual working. This is the most impressive feature for me I think, on-the-fly, keyboard/mouse, just use the hardware that you’re using for desk computing anyway and complete control of the phone. So on one side of the Windows screen you can have the virtual phone and on the other, sweep the mouse off to the left for control of the ‘real’ phone (see Cross Control, below). And if you open up the side panel on the PC the phone unlocks, then just glance at the phone for Face Unlock and it’s done - you’re in (depending on phone settings of course).

Smart Clipboard is more robust/faster than Google’s QuickShare.

App Streaming is more robust than Microsoft Phone Link’s (particularly for us serial phone-swappers)!

Cross Control is every bit as good as Windows’ multi-monitor setup (or whatever it’s called) where the mouse slides across and off the edge of the Windows screen straight onto the phones, smartly working out then where the keyboard should work too.

Webcam I used last week when we were having to use Zoom instead of Skype for a podcast recording - as my PC has no camera - and it worked perfectly, using the phone pointing at me, hooked up to Zoom.

Hotspot is fine, though it does work without Moto of course.

HDMI-Out to TV if needed (with all the tools there too - and a big-buttoned front-end - so you can use your telly as a PC if you like).

Mobile Desktop which gives you an on-the-fly UI to turn any display into a PC or TV (with big-buttons if wanted).

Files and Share Hub are more robust than relying on Windows Explorer to move stuff around, which remains flakey (particularly for multiple commands and large amounts of data with Android).

Virtual keyboard settings on the phone - and a Smart Connect sub-menu - in portrait or landscape (which I only just discovered)!

Little Impact on battery (even when not cabled up and going wireless) in my tests is completely minimal. Or for the paranoid/untrusting, just sit it on a Qi Charger whilst doing all the above!

It’s all very clever and I’m trying to keep up! Moto are really pushing the boat out with this. All these tools and more are great, bundled into one package but, same as Apple, they all depend on the user being baked-into the Moto way and using Windows (for Moto’s Smart Connect software). I do prefer these tools over DeX now and am getting sold rapidly on wireless over wired with zero latency and a good, robust network.

Back to the phone, there’s the other features like 125W charging, with brick in the box, 50W Qi (not that I have a charger for that!), 512GB/12GB, 3x Optical Zoom, f1.4 on the main OIS 50MP cam, AF in wide-angle for impressive close-ups, very good stereo speakers, IP6/8 and 3 OS updates/4 years security.

Moto Tags should be coming soon, promised by Moto PR. They are now on sale at AmazonUK at £99 for 4 (singles not yet readily available) - but the whole Android Find My Device relies on Google getting their finger out and giving the v’s-up to security and user-choice like Apple and Samsung have done! The Android 15 turn Bluetooth back on tomorrow will help - and although it can be disabled, Joe Bloggs is not going to bother!

Anyway, I just thought I'd share my thoughts. I know I've said most of this before, but a good reminder of enjoying the Moto way as they continue to take on Samsung! Here's a link to my full review of the Motorola Edge 50 Pro.

Oraolo Wearable Bluetooth Speaker

I do like Bluetooth speakers. You may have noticed! I always seem to have trouble with in-ear buds staying in my right ear. Left is fine. Right is not. I'm clearly deformed! I've tried all sorts of tricks and followed all sorts of tips (literally)! But nothing works. So most of the time it's over the ears/head headphones for me.

I know I shouldn't care about wearing headphones out and about doing my steps in the public arena, but I do. I feel a bit of a numpty. However people reassure me and however many youngsters I see doing it without a care in the world it seems, I just don't feel 'right' about it somehow. So I'm always looking for new ways to listen to music and this time have ended up with something completely new to me, a clip-on speaker known as the Oraolo Wearable BT Speaker!

Amazon has quite a lot of these, mostly, nay all of them, I think, out of China with wildly varying prices - and reviews from people buying them. There are the expensive Sony neckband units which I'm sure are really good (and a load of cheap copies of that) but it seems that there's a lot of cheap rubbish that needs wading through, which I did before settling on this one. Buy one for a tenner and you get what you pay for, to a large degree, it seems. This one's list price is £108.99 today, which is equally absurd! Fortunately, like a good MFI dining room table, it's always on sale - usually with at least 50% off - so bide your time if you're going to, as I got the 50% and a 27% Voucher and ended up paying about £22 for mine! And I think that at that price, it's about right.

It's a neat-looking black unit with a power button up the top of the front, for turning on/off and pairing and underneath, a grille/mesh covering the rest, with big JBL-style plus and minus clicky buttons for volume, primarily. The click is nice and firm. It's the best part of 3" long, just over an inch fat and an inch and a half wide. Then, on the back, there's the 'clip'. It's a strong, sturdy clip which doesn't feel like it's going to break anytime soon. It's almost as wide as the unit itself so affords a good grip to whatever you clip it to. As you can see from the diagram, it's 2.2oz, which is just over 60g, so hanging from a shirt or lapel is really no problem and I have found it to be hardly noticeable. The clip opens up quite broadly so it can be clipped to backpacks, bags or whatever but it's certainly not broad enough to be clipped onto the average bike frame/handlebar - still I guess it can then be clipped to something else on a bike, like a saddle - or probably more sensibly, clothing anyway!

Apart from adjusting the volume up and down, the track can be moved along by long-pressing either of the two plus/minus buttons, but bizarrely, it's minus for forward and plus for back! What? Who thought that would be a good idea, I wonder! The power button is also used for play/pause and answer/end calls. I've tried to invoke Gemini (Live) by using the device itself but can't find a way, however, if you start the conversation on the phone whilst the device is paired and active, you can then walk away from the phone and keep the conversation going both ways with just the speaker. Notifications don't seem to make it through in my testing, like they do with all the same gear but with headphones/buds, this is usually largely down to supporting software/apps, which this doesn't have. So it's really more of a listening/phone calls device. It pairs up quickly and easily and the range away from source actually seems quite impressive with Bluetooth.

The sound is actually quite good. It's not going to win any awards for quality, but it is better and louder than any mobile phone I have ever tried. Not surprising as it would need to be a giant phone to house a speaker the size that's in this thing, dinky as it is! I played around with various phones and their respective Equalisers, even tried out the Wavelet app which we often speak warmly about, and yes, as usual, you can make the sound better than it is without these tools. And there's plenty of volume to play with, so the usual payoff with phones becomes insignificant in that respect.

Out and about is tricky, of course. I have tried it but you have to be very aware of folk around you and not annoying them, as with any sound that's not in one's ears. The bloke on the bus comes to mind! But walking along, alone, it's fine. In amongst loud traffic it's not really. This is for more rural, quieter environments. I have it clipped to my shirt above my sternum and that seems to work well. I did try it clipped to my rucksack's strap on my shoulder whilst in loud traffic, which made it better of course as it's nearer to at least one ear!

It's not just for out and about though. There are domestic uses too, like for example, I had it hooked up to my Roku Streambar, attached to my telly, across the room. That gets the sound of the TV next to the viewer. No stereo of course, but the channels do get routed into mono of course, so you don't lose any of it. And wandering around the house, too, make a cup of tea, go to the loo! And the added benefit over ear/headphones that you can clearly hear what's going on around you if, for example, the doorbell is rung.

The battery supposedly lasts for 18 hours and charges with the supplied USB-A to USB-C cable (or any other one you have). Well, in my tests it actually lasted about 8-10 hours on 100% volume. To get 18 hours, you'd have to have it at 60%, they say in the blurb. It charges up from flat in about 90 minutes. It's supposed to waterproof (to some degree) but I have not tested that!

Anyway, that's been my quick thoughts on the unit and I'm very pleased to have it as an option for when I give up, yet again, with earphones and don't want to use headphones or blast the neighbours with my Marshall Acton III! I do have the JBL Clip 5 but small as that is, it's still not as dinky and light as this one - although you do get significantly better sound. If you get it for the same £22 that I did, then it's certainly worth the outlay. Any more and I wouldn't have bothered.

All the Bright Places (2020)

This is an incredibly moving portrait of four (or more) deeply troubled teens who, although living in privileged situations in America, are dealing, have been dealing and will be dealing with various tragedies in their lives. It's based on Jennifer Niven's apparently poignant novel of the same name, which I have not read.

It's an exploration of mental health, tragedy, suicide, anxiety and abuse which lingers on the hope of recovery. The story focuses mainly on our two central characters, Violet, played by Elle Fanning and Finch, enacted by Justice Smith. We join the tale as Violet is stood on the rail of a bridge, looking down at the long drop on what would have been her sister's 19th birthday. In fact, the bridge was the very location where her sister had died in a car accident.

Finch happens along as he's out running and engages with Violet, trying to find out what's going on and to prevent the situation getting worse for her and those who might be impacted by yet another tragedy. As the two start to spend time together, Violet's depression and outlook start to shift, slowly and with much input, reflection and care from Finch.

We spend a good portion of the first quarter of the film with Violet, observing her grief, continuing months after the tragedy, her not pulling herself out of the depression, whilst others around her do what they can to encourage recovery. Fanning plays this beautifully. When she smiles, she has a lovely smile but when her face is at rest, it does have a ready look of poignancy about it, fit for the role here.

The human connection builds between them, two troubled souls who find solace in each other (as we start to also have Finch's problematic background thrown into the mix), beginning a journey of self-discovery and healing. They end up executing a school project together - visiting all the bright places in rural Indiana, which, incidentally, are shot beautifully. The locations, to some degree, do the job for themselves, but the cinematography is taken a notch further than just that - in fact a big notch as it becomes a visual delight.

The focus of the film remains very much about mental illness though and director Brett Haley makes sure that it remains so throughout. It deals with it intelligently and sympathetically (rather than trying to sensationalise outcomes) using the great talent on display here. I've become a fan of Elle Fanning and have written about her performance in The Roads Not Taken (2020) and should have, but didn't, about her depiction of Woody Allen's 'Ashleigh' character in his 2019 film A Rainy Day in New York. She simply sparkled in that, under his direction.

Justice Smith is equally capable and captivating here, as the chemistry between the two leads carries the film. It is a moving and emotional film and Fanning plays Violet's grief heartbreakingly well, but it's smart, powerful and thought-provoking, not gushy. An excellently created film which hopefully could go some way to helping people who suffer with similar mental health issues and/or tragedy in their lives. Otherwise, yes, watch it for the super performances of the two leads.

Sweetpea (2024)

The bug-eyed Ella Purnell (no wonder Tim Burton snapped her up for Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children) stars as Rhiannon who works at the local newspaper as a receptionist but has her eyes set on becoming a reporter.

Her dad has just died, she was bullied at school by the nasty Julia, played by Nicôle Lecky, her sister wants to sell dad's house, where Rhiannon lives, so our plucky, loopy, central character takes matters of life and death into her own hands in order to sort out the mess!

Ella Purnell, working with a storyline which was, frankly, a bit stretched, does a fabulous job as she switches from Sweetpea into serial killer and kidnapper! Her character has clearly got a screw loose, which throughout the narrative seems to be blamed on Julia at school, her bullying, and Rhiannon's declining mental health as she pulls her hair out in her anxiety. She's a terrific British actress who is always great to watch and seems to be able to turn her craft to various genres and characters. She's funny, entertaining and hugely engaging to watch.

I guess it becomes a crime drama, but is certainly darkly comic throughout as we follow Rhiannon closely through Now/SkyTV's six 40 minute episodes, available just now in the UK. 

Now a budding junior reporter, she bizarrely picks up the story reporting on her own crimes, whilst manipulating those around her, gaining confidence as she goes, almost getting caught time and again and being prepared to use her sexuality in order to fuel her fantasy world, to get what she wants. Leah Harvey plays the chasing detective working on a hunch (which her boss won't let her run with) very nicely too. In fact, all the players do a good job and are clearly having fun with the outing.

Yes, you can pick fault with some of the decisions she and those around her make, but don't forget that it's comedy, dark as it maybe - here and there even turning to farce. But the driving tone is certainly the darkness and if you watch it with that in mind, you'll have a great ride and enjoy it thoroughly. I really enjoyed it, anyway, and it ends clearly pointing at a second series - so I hope very much that it will be done!

Outside (2024)

This has just dropped into Netflix and it appears to be a film out of the Philippines. It's a kind-of Zombie muncher but there's not that much Zombie action in it until the last half-hour, when it ramps up and goes bonkers!

The rest of it is quite slow, not terribly well acted, quite atmospheric, I guess, but the background to the characters takes far too long to come out and it's not that critical to know it. I'd say jump into the middle somewhere knowing that it's a family who are trying to survive or consider 'heading north' for some (alleged) sanctuary. (Where have we heard that before?!)

On the way they decide to set up camp at dad's (now dead) parents' house - where most of the action/inaction happens for the rest of the film. It was OK. Most of the budget went on the Zombie body-parts and blood! The last half-hour made it worth the visit!

Humanist Vampire Seeking Consenting Suicidal Person (2023)

I do love a good vampire romp and this French one felt very much like a class above many - as the youngest daughter of our family in focus, if 68 is young, isn't very committed to the idea of killing for her feeds, so relies on the family around her to supply her blood. Furthermore, her fangs won't come out properly yet so she couldn't even if she wanted to! She's certainly a cowardly, thoughtful vamp with a conscience!

It's all very tongue-in-cheek and at times has the flair and comic feel of Amelie, especially with the 'removed from reality' dreamer Sasha, the girl in question. Fortunately for her, she stumbles into a young chappie who hates his life so much, bullied by those around him, that he's considering suicide. When he discovers the truth about Sasha and her little problem, he offers himself up to her, as he wants to die anyway, to help her get past her block!

Sarah Montpetit plays Sasha and Félix-Antoine Bénard, Paul, the bloke who wants to top himself. She plays it delightfully, charmingly and engagingly. Reminded me very much of the Goth girlfriend of Jesse, Jane, in Breaking Bad actually, played by Krysten Ritter! I don't know either of the actors but the inexperienced director Ariane Louis-Seize has picked them both well. This is her first full feature film, I think, and the French title is Vampire humaniste cherche suicidaire consentant.

Various members of her family also play their roles nicely, especially her cousin, mum, dad and aunt. They are all playing it for fun until the tone of the film somewhat switches partway through. Moreso away from comedy, though that remains to a degree, darkly, and towards a sad picture of loneliness, abuse amongst nasty school kids, love and emotion between mainly the two leads before they vamp-up the finale for a fun last act.

It's great fun, considered and thoughtful, cute and dark - very dark in places - and well worth a look if you can grab it - currently doing a stint on Mubi in the UK. It's only 90 minutes long, but it's a feast to watch the vamp-feasting on others, if and when they can! Terrific!

Janet Planet (2023)

In rural Western Massachusetts, 11-year-old Lacy spends the summer of 1991 at home, enthralled by her own imagination and the attention of her mother, Janet. As the months pass, three visitors enter their orbit, all captivated by Janet (says IMDb). This brings new meaning to the phrase slow burner. It really is almost stationary.

Annie Baker (who has made the leap for the first time from theatre, plays and writing to directing) lingers long on people, places, scenes and poignant silences. It feels very arthouse in many ways - a close-up and personal character study which viewers can - and will - take away different stuff.

I really like Julianne Nicholson, and have done since her cutesy appearance back in Ally McBeal, who takes the lead here with daughter Lacy, played beautifully by Zoe Ziegler. She's far from cutesy these days and especially here, but is a terrific actress portraying the hippy-mum with a liberated past, floating in and out of relationships.

There are three characters who float in and out of Janet and Lacy's lives during the course of our story, presented as chapters, and demonstrate quite clearly the difficulties Janet has holding on to anything and showing why it is that Lacy has ended up reclusive with no friends, an unconfident bag of nerves.

Will Patton plays the first floater, at the outset as Janet's partner Wayne, Sophie Okonedo as Regina, a long-lost friend from the past and Elias Koteas as Avi, the philosophising guru in charge of the hippy-cult (or perhaps not a cult!) and theatrical troupe. They all three play their parts well, in keeping with what Baker demands of them. It's shot beautifully with lasting visuals as she's not afraid to wait. And wait. At one point, we watch some food being microwaved. For half a minute. In real time. Try and work out what that's about, apart from reflecting the pacing of the general delivery of the film/story.

Some of the time, we wonder what's actually happening and what's conjured up in the minds of Janet and Lacy, especially towards the end, but that takes nothing from the intended engagement for the audience.

It's quite hard to review this film really as everyone will view it differently and develop their own interpretation but in order to get to that point, people will have to be patient as yes, the near-2 hours often feels like it's dragging and well, nothing much is happening. You really have to look past that and try to digest something different. Or not bother! Various streaming services have it bouncing around if you fancy a bit of naval-gazing with the two leads!

The Lodge (2019)

Pay attention during the first 10 minutes of this film. That’s all I’ll say on that before diving into the storyline - which is about a family that is breaking apart, with dad finding a new woman and mum devastated. Dad’s new woman is Grace, appropriately-named, as it turns out she’s got a history of having been part of a religious cult which didn’t end well!

She’s medicated up, in control, and trying to start a new life - but dad’s two brats are having none of it, especially when circumstances throw them into a lodge in the middle of nowhere without their mum, determined to ensure that Grace knows they are not happy with the new situation. Dad is trying hard to get them to accept Grace of course, as he’s madly in love with her.

It’s a snowy lodge. There’s a storm. Dad has to go back to the city to work for a couple of days so leaves Grace and the two kids to try to get along together, get to know each other and find some common ground. Grace is played by Riley Keough (Mad Max: Fury Road, The Guilty) and clearly the majority of the budget is spent on her fee as the rest of it comes across as a pretty low-budget outing. The girl and boy do decent enough jobs, Jaeden Martell (It, Knives Out) and Lia McHugh, but the stage really belongs to Keough, who carries off the central role very well.

As the ice begins to melt between the three of them, some strange goings on start to happen and we enter a bit of an apparent eerie, spook-fest as everyone’s scrabbling around to try to make sense of it all. When Grace’s medication goes missing, a whole new line of strange starts as she begins to panic and lose control.

Director team Severin Fiala and Veronika Franz (Goodnight Mommy, The Devil’s Bath) spend much of their energy creating elongated periods of tense atmosphere, which is to a large degree successful - especially when (inevitably) the lights go off, power’s cut, phones don't work, house is creepy - you know the drill! Add into the mix Grace losing the plot and we have the makings for a half decent spooky thriller - with a few surprises in store and a finale worth the wait! It’s been around for a while and now streaming on various outlets. Well worth a watch.

Level 16 (2018)

This is a story based around a bonkers idea, which I won’t spoil for you here as it will take away most of the enjoyment of the build-up to the big reveal as to what’s behind it all, what’s going on and why! You can enjoy the journey instead if you fancy the challenge as it’s available now on various streaming services.

We spend almost all of director Danishka Esterhazy’s (The Banana Splits Movie) film inside what appears to be a very regimented girls boarding school, though it looks much more like a prison.

The girls are all mid-teens (on Level 16) and younger, we assume - as we don’t see any - on lower (or different) levels. There appears to be about a dozen girls on each level and a strict, tall blond woman, Miss Brixil, played by Sara Canning (The Vampire Diaries), who keeps them all behaving as they should. They need to be ‘clean girls’ and follow the strict rules. If they don’t they are dragged off by a couple of henchmen and ‘punished’ (which we don’t see) or locked in a box/cage (which we do).

Vivien, played by Katie Douglas (Ginny & Georgia) is not accepting this whole scenario and tries to rebel, dragging the not-so-convinced Sophia, played by Celina Martin (The Banana Splits Movie), along with her rebellious intentions. To get out of the place. She doesn’t believe that the air outside is ‘poisoned’ and plots an escape between pretending to conform and being suspected by the nice-on-the-face-of-it doctor in charge of the ‘vitamins’ the girls have to take and injections of nasty stuff to keep them in line if meandering from the path! That’s about the set up really, anything else would be a reveal, so I’ll leave you to it.

The acting is decent enough, particularly by the leads, the tone is sinister and keeps you guessing (there are clues for those who look) until the final act. The whole thing feels very low-budget, which it probably is, but it’s well produced, directed and executed for a fun 102 minutes!

Motorola Edge 50 Neo

Before I get to the ThinkPhone25 vs Moto Edge 50 Neo comparison, I thought I'd do the more logical bunch of thoughts, that being the Edge 50 Neo vs Edge 40 Neo (and possibly sprinkled with some Edge 30 Neo flavouring)! And a bunch of other Moto phones here - it's an addiction! The Edge 50 Neo, released in August 2024, was reduced on AmazonUK Prime Day in October 2024 and frankly, as a Moto Maniac (and MOTOvator!) I couldn't resist it! If Moto PR now send me one too, well, that'll be a brace of braces I have here to decide what to do with!

As is traditional, then - to the unboxing. But before I do, I'll throw in some links to my other recent Moto hardware reviews, thoughts and comparison, to which this piece will refer. ThinkPhone 25 vs ThinkPhone, G Stylus (2024), Edge 50 Pro, Buds+, Edge 40, Edge 40 Neo, ThinkPhone, Edge 30 Neo and Edge 30 Ultra. That's probably far enough back!

The box that the Edge 50 Neo comes in is the now-usual for Moto - plastic-free, recyclable buff colour - and it's clear immediately that there's no charger in the box, as it's that smaller, flatter type. 68W charging it is, but bring-your-own-brick! I guess that's a cost-saving measure. The same perfume/fragrance is present during the unboxing, now common with most of Moto's phones and along with a USB-C to USB-C cable, papers and SIM Tray tool, there's a colour-matched case - which a leaflet informs us is made by some Swedish firm called "agood company"! The case is a good-looking 'wrap around' case, all but for the cutouts where they need to be, enveloping the 5 sides/edges that are not screen. Kudos to them for not putting annoying TPU over the volume and power buttons, but leaving them open. Nice one Moto.

The phone itself is, for me, such a lovely size. It's a tad taller and wider than my Pixel 8 (which was not far from being the perfect size itself), giving a bit more screen for viewing at 6.36" (over the Pixel 8's 6.1"). My phone is the Pantone shade of Poinciana (a bold orangey-red) but it's also available in Nautical Blue, Latte (like the drink's colour) and a kind of blue/grey Grisaille. I reckon this red one is the best! The colour is also matched around the frame of the phone, which is plastic-looking-like-aluminium, with slightly chamfered edges, making the slim sides not quite flat all-over.

On the right, we have the volume rocker (looking like buttons) above the power button, clustered two-thirds of the way up the side. At the top we have a microphone beside the Dolby Atmos emblem, on the left there's nothing and on the bottom, SIM Card Tray, main microphone, USB-C port and one of the two stereo speakers. On the back there's a sizeable camera island top-left in portrait, an 'M' logo in the middle and under that, Pantone's badge denoting the device's colour in their range. The camera island slopes up from the bottom and right, now becoming fairly 'signature' for Moto design these days - and on that, four circles, making up the camera-cluster, which we'll come to.

The back is 'silicone polymer' (otherwise known as eco-leather) which is also becoming fairly standard for Moto phones, at least in the UK. I have written about this in my other reviews linked to above, but yes - it's a nice velvety, slightly grippy texture, much better than the plastic the phone is coming in, in some regions - and certainly glass! The supplied case, to which I refer above, is slightly more slippery, but as the phone is so small, I don't think gripping it in the hand will be anything like as problematic as it would for, say, a 6.7" phone.

The front is a flat panel with curved corners, the second speaker up the top in the middle between the glass and frame, sitting above the centralised Selfie camera cutout - which is not terribly big or intrusive compared to some. The screen has been rated Gorilla Glass 3 for protection, which is not the best these days, so for those less careful than me, you might want to track down and install a decent screen protector. If you must!

The nanoSIM Card Tray holds just that - one nanoSIM Card with the back blocked where a second could live, so maybe in some regions there's a dual-SIM variant using the same tray, unblocked! There is also eSIM capability in the phone.

The phone is pretty light, as you might expect at this size and with a plastic frame (171g) but they have somehow made it IP6/8 rated for water/dust and, amazingly, MIL-STD-810H compliant! This is a phone which was designed to be rugged, though not perhaps in keeping with the use of the aforementioned Gorilla Glass 3, sadly. But as for out and about, Moto claim that it'll work fine up to 60 degrees centigrade and also down to minus 20. I wonder who might test that!

The setup procedure was painless, utilising the getting-more-smart Android system of using the old phone's camera to scan a QR Code on the new, knowing the old phone's WiFi/Router password/login, then asking about default browser and set up fingerprint scanner. Then confirm that you're going to accept a few "from Motorola" apps (but there's actually no choice!) Adobe Scan (Uninstallable), Booking dot Com (Uninstallable), Opera Browser with AI (Uninstallable), Opera News (Uninstallable), LinkedIn (Uninstallable) and a few Google standard ones - then away it goes, wirelessly (no offer of cabled). My baseline (saying no to film/TV but including Music) was about 40GB, which then takes about 20 minutes. Homescreen layout just as it was on the Edge 50 Pro, which I used for the transfer, though Wallpaper didn't survive the switch.

The phone has the MediaTek Dimensity 7300 (4nm) which also appeared in the Razr 50 (not Ultra), G Power and has also been seen in the likes of the CMF Phone (1) along with a long list of phones originated in the far-east from the likes of RealMe, Vivo, Oppo et al. The proof of the pudding is in the eating and based on early use, the phone seems perfectly responsive for the everyday. During the initial setup you could tell that this was no blazingly fast SnapDragon, copying files over, installing/updating 100+ apps from the Playstore, running the camera software at the same time as YouTube Music, for example - these processor-demanding combinations of tasks will show where the cost-shaving has happened, but for 98% of users, after setup (or even during), they simply won't notice. The 98% won't give a stuff about benchmarks, but just get on and use it.

I've also tested out the chipset's performance during relatively demanding car-racing gaming tasks and again, I've not found a judder nor jolt in framerates, making the chipset a decent value-choice by Moto, it would seem. Talking of which, you get the Gametime front-end when Gaming if you want to use it - a simple app-organiser then control-panel once playing to see what the phone's doing in terms of processing power, RAM and so on, with various toggles to throw if you don't want to be connected/disturbed etc. The usual thing. Can't say I'm really much of a gamer, but it all looks like a useful bunch of tools/controls for those who are.

This particular unit has got 256GB of storage onboard and 8GB RAM. Apparently there is/will be a 512GB/12GB variant out there, too, but from what I've seen in daily use here, the storage is a perfectly good amount for my uses (though more is always better, of course) and juggling open apps, once all set up and running, it seems to dance the merry tune well enough. Plenty (staying) open and I think that if any glitch is noticed, it's more to do with the chipset than RAM frankly - but as I said above, it really is quite a smooth experience all-round. There's no microSD Card slot, as I said. Oh yes, you can also boost the RAM by nicking some from storage, but as reported previously, I wouldn't bother!

The annoying Moto App Manager is pre-installed which means unless you're careful and don't agree to them bombarding you with 'helpful suggested apps' on 'occasional auto-download' that's what'll happen. Usually a bunch of crappy games every few days, fit for 2-year-olds. So head to Settings, Apps and Force Close/Disable that app so it can't! And if you ignore it or say 'no' it'll ask again every few days. Beware also that it might rekindle itself after OS or Security updates. Naughty Moto.

The bang-up-to-date Wallpaper>Create with AI>Magic Canvas is present, like on the Razr 50 Ultra (but not yet Edge 50 Pro - or any other Moto I have), which is an image generator (like now in Gemini and loads of other AI tools out there) baked-in. So tell it to generate a picture for you - I dunno, a cat with a top-hat - and it will. Nothing unique particularly but certainly a sign moving forward showing that Moto is thinking about and executing AI features to keep up with the Big Boys.

An Always On Display! Yay! Again, only present otherwise on a Moto on the Razr 50 Ultra flip-phone, this now baked into ROM here too. There's no choice - it's that hollow-clock design, with day, date and Weather data below it, Notification 'bubbles' if that's your style towards the foot, fingerprint scanner below, sitting on top of the Battery percentage. Well done Moto. It's been an awful long time since we had an AoD on a Moto phone, then preferring their 'Peek' display for some years, then for a while, pretty much nothing other than Lock Screen on move/nudge/lift. This is great! And it seems to follow the brightness of the system-wide setting. So if you put the Brightness on 100% then so will this AoD be so. Choose Adaptive Brightness and it'll follow that and (supposedly) become 'trained' by your use-patterns. Early days, but it looks like it might be doing so!

The stonkin' news from Moto is that, at last, they've responded to market (or tech-press) pressure, following Google, Samsung, Apple and (growingly) others by offering long update support. This is the first Moto phone which offers 5 OS updates (so, arriving on Android 14, it'll get Android 19 following Google's release in Q42028) and Google Security Patches to August 2029. Out of the box in October 2024 here, it updated with September 2024's Google Security patches (and Google also pushed September's Play System update). This is much, much better Moto. Don't let your customers down by squelching on the deal early, pretty please! With no 'folding' screen involved and the military ruggedisation, who knows - the handset might just last that long too!

Anyway, I seem to be jumping about all over the place now, so will get back on track and look at the screen. It's a 6.36" LTPO (so will help with the AoD) P-OLED which maxes out at 120Hz as a refresh-rate. This can be set to 60Hz or placed into Auto mode and yes, because of the LTPO, can get itself right down to 1Hz. It's HDR10+ compliant with the usual Moto stonking brightness and colours, putting many others to shame. It apparently peaks (in auto brightness) at 3000nits. The pixel count is 474 per inch, generated within the 1256 x 2760 equipped front panel. You can shift the colour intensity in settings between natural, vivid, radiant and/or the colour temperature manually - or via pre-sets.

I can't praise (what we still think is) LG-supplied Moto phone P-OLED screens enough and this is no exception - mid-range or not. Quite stunning. It's a flat panel with minimal bezels and at this pocket/hand-friendly size, is a delight to use. I can reach everywhere on the screen with my relatively large hands, one-handed. Just be careful of micro-scratches over the 5 years of ownership on that GG3! Perhaps a screen protector is a good idea, after all!

The stereo speakers, in keeping generally with the Neo line from Moto, put some of their other models to shame as the sound is loud, good quality and will, again, please the 98% very much. There's good stereo separation even without any of the included Dolby Atmos tools and equalisation, so much so that I have not really felt the need to switch from the default settings. It's not going to pass any audiophile's test, but then very few mobile phones will really, if we're going to get picky. For me, it's not far away from the quality of the Sony Xperia range of phones - and is actually louder. Very happy with this.

There's no 3.5mm audio-out on this model, so for head/earphones it's a USB-C route or Bluetooth (5.3 here). Both of which, as always depending on attached equipment, sound fabulous. Particularly too with Moto's own Buds+ (see above), which is what one might expect. Rich and powerful, tested here with a range of head/earphones including Sony WH-1000XM4, AKG K701, Sony MDR-7506/1, Google's own USB-C Wired and more.

The fingerprint scanner is an under-glass optical one and in isolation it's not the best out there. It works fine with a 'linger' rather than instantaneously. I'm surprised that they didn't put a capacitive one in the power button really at this price-point. Don't get me wrong, it's perfectly functional - just not as blazing fast as some, especially ultrasonic ones - but yes, certainly not capacitive. It's quick and easy to set up. Fortunately the double-barrelled approach to getting-in offers Face Unlock too - and this works flawlessly in my tests - even in dubious lighting. So by the time one's finger is on the screen, you're in and open by face anyway. A good duo of options working together well.

The phone is physically smaller than most (these days) so that needs to be taken into account with the size of the battery that can be crammed inside. They've managed to get in a 4,310mAh unit which, lets face it, is only a bit bigger than the Razr 50 Ultra flip-phone! But actually, on initial testing, taking into account the power-efficient chipset (and even AoD), I have been pleasantly surprised with the performance. My 10% Reading Test returned about two and a half to three hours - pretty much up there with the Edge 50 Pro. Similarly, the Average Daily Test for my use, projected up at this early stage, is likely getting me all-but two days between charges. Obviously everyone's usage pattern is going to be different, so YMMV. I guess it's very much about that chipset component optimisation and smart software. No complaints.

If you are a heavy user, there's also 68W charging, so armed with a brick supporting that, you can get a quick charge. Moto claim that the battery should last "over 34 hours" and that you can "fuel up for the day in 11 minutes". This seems to mean "12 hours of battery life in 11 minutes charge" with a "substantially depleted" battery and with "charge boost" on. Which is in settings. With a warning that it might heat up the phone! They also only claim that you'll get 68W with Moto's own TurboPower charger (that they will sell you for £25.99) but I've been using my UGreen 100W GaN charger with similar results - and the 125W TurboPower charger that comes with various flagship Moto phones here, as you might expect, does the job. Anyway, apparently using the Moto 68W TurboPower you can get from 0-100 in under 40 minutes and nearly 90% within a half-hour.

More impressively at this price-point is that Wireless Qi Charging being included - and will do so at 15W. I have also been testing this with various bedside trickle-chargers and wake up after 6/7 hours sleep with a full charge, AoD on too (which is more than I can say for the Razr 50 Ultra - see my review). It's very convenient to charge like this overnight, though I do understand that it's not energy-efficient to some degree. Here you have both options and in my testing, I wouldn't worry about needing to buy proprietary chargers like you'd have to with BBK Group phones, for example.

HelloUI is Moto's latest Android 'skin' and present here. Unlike some, it's a minimalist skin but brings a fairly feature-rich experience, whilst retaining what's good about a Vanilla Android experience too. It's a smart mix which most don't get right. So often over the top, sometimes dumbed-down. Motorola has included lots of ways in which to change and personalise many elements of the UI including fonts, icon shapes, colours, themes, Lock Screen (now customisable), smart volume controls and more. It's nothing like the Samsung playground open to developers, culminating in a marketplace, but there's still lots of tweaks. Some new, some old.

The Sidebar is fairly new, where apps/tools/shortcuts can be assigned to a quick-release panel on the side of any screen and offers the option to open any one of them full-screen or in a floating window - which can then be resized, minimised (in terms of not having a top-menu) or shrunk to the edge of the screen as a quick-tap button. The button can be moved around and placed where the user likes, in order to quickly snap it open again. This is just one example amongst many features that Moto users have been more used to - like three-finger screenshot, chop-chop for torch, twist-twist for camera, split-screening and so on. The gesture support like this adds useful functionality without going overboard.

Moto have also gone all-in on device and accounts security, in addition to what Android itself now offers, since it was all baked into the ThinkPhone for corporations. ThinkShield, MotoSecure and MotoAI working together to protect the user with various scanning/notification/fixing tools for stuff like phishing detection. The whole front-end looks and feels like it's well thought out, implemented and designed for the benefit of users rather than just money-spinning by the firm, or third parties.

The cherry on the cake is how Moto have taken on Samsung's DeX and, in some ways, come out on top with Smart Connect. This will be a matter of opinion, and both have pros and cons, but I like what moto have done here with the user-friendly, button-driven front-end that you don't get in DeX and is much more flexible than the likes of Phone Link from Microsoft (though admittedly not universal like that). HDMI-Out is not supported here, so you can't plug into a cable and use the phone as the 'brains' for an external monitor or, for example, NexDock or TV by cable, but Moto (and Samsung) apart from with a PC, seem to be assuming that everyone's doing everything wirelessly these days - so they will too.

Almost all recent Moto phones have Smart Connect (previously Ready For) functionality which means that sat in front of a PC with Smart Connect Windows software installed, the user can either wirelessly or with a cable (yes, even if there's no HDMI-Out functionality via USB-C) hook up the phone and computer to enjoy a range of interrelated functions. Phone on PC echoes your phone's screen at the side of the Windows PC's screen with a tag on the side to pop it in and out of the way as needed. You can use the phone via the PC's keyboard, mouse, touchscreen, stylus, whatever control you have available, as-if it's in your hand and you're using the phone. This includes audio and video pass-through and connected via network/Bluetooth, in my tests here, there's near zero latency.

There's a Smart Clipboard which means everything you 'clip' on the phone or PC is instantly available on the other, much faster than Google's QuickShare (though again, that system is not locked down to Moto, rather universal for Windows/Android). App Streaming, which lets you call up any app and use it in a phone-shaped window on the PC (much like you can using Phone on PC and Phone Link), pass-through Webcam use for any messaging apps you fancy - or just shooting video, a Files function which gives very fast file management of your phone in a Windows Explorer window on the PC for moving/managing files and folders between the hardware, Hotspot - to instantly use your phone's connection to get the PC online, Share Hub - which does much like the Files app but the emphasis on quick drag'n'drop, Cross Control where you can use a multi-windowed environment to assign screens where you like then use the mouse of the PC to 'flow' to the assigned screen. For example, if you place the phone's screen to the left of the main window, you can then use the PC's mouse to slide off from the left of the PC's screen and straight on the phone's screen - then control the phone on-the-fly, and lastly Mobile Desktop in which, DeX style, the system creates a virtual Windows-style Desktop environment for windowing, scrolling, resizing - whatever you like really. Using your computer's screen, mouse, keyboard and anything plugged into it, but with the 'brains' of the operation being the phone.

All this is where I have found no problem with the 8GB RAM being able to control all of this on-the-fly, no hitch, with the phone's Dimensity chipset keeping up without issue. It's fascinating to play with and for many, no doubt, becoming productive. It would be more useful if it worked via HDMI to 'dumb' monitors or TVs, but certainly the latter works beautifully well wirelessly. More expensive Moto phones do this, case in point being the Edge 50 Pro here (though not Razr 50 Ultra).

The TV/monitor experience is similarly big-button-driven, making it easy-access for casual users to use their phone as a servant, screen as a monitor, or those who want to use a TV to dive into Desktop Mode and get to work. Anyway, that was rather a long spiel depicting the good stuff that Moto have been working on and appear to be taking seriously with Smart Connect. With recent announcements from Google working in partnership now with Moto, it can only look better going forward.

Connectivity using the phone seems positive so far. I've tested both the 4G and 5G cellular with voice and data without issue in various locations, GPS seems good with swift locking/tracking in various apps, NFC I have tested with reliable results for hooking up equipment (like Bluetooth headphones) and at shop checkouts using Google Wallet for payments. Pickup range is good and reliable. WiFi has been tested on 3 networks and seems to be good at each, so no problem - and Bluetooth range seems reliable and far-reaching compared to some. It seems that Motorola have continued to use good aerials/components for even mid-range phones like this one and not just flagships.

Now to my least favourite part, the camera! Well, it is usually and at this point I regularly hand you over to our friends at GSMArena. At this point however, they haven't yet done a full review so instead, here's their Camera and Early Verdict page while I launch into a general overview and layman's impressions here! The main camera is a 50MP f1.8 unit with OIS (not the f1.4 version which comes with more expensive recent models). The secondary camera is a 10MP f/2 telephoto shooter, again with OIS, and this time a 3x optical zoom. There's a 3rd lens which forms the wide-angle functions, 13MP f/2.2 with AF enabling very good close-up shots. Video can be shot at 4K@30fps or 1080p@240fps, so no 8K and only gyro-EIS in the mix. There's a 32MP f/2.4 Selfie camera round the front, as I said earlier, top-centre screen, punchout.

General consensus from those who know much more about digital photography than me is that photos shot in good light are pretty pleasing and that even when it gets a bit darker the software goes to work in order to create perfectly acceptable, for most uses, results. The zoom shots come out well, again, better in decent light than not - though the camera's Night Vision doesn't do too bad a job. There's a Pro mode for those who want to tinker manually, the usual Moto 'toys' like Spot Colour and Photo Booth - and also the ability to shoot at full 50MP resolution rather than the quad-bayer chopdown to 12MP. The Portrait function allows for different virtual focal lengths (equiv. 35mm) and there's even an 'f stop' slider to emulate bokeh on-the-fly. The AF in the wide-angle creates very nice so-called 'macro' shots - very close indeed - and not via a dreadful 2MP 'macro lens' like on so many others, even in this price-range. When GSMArena do their full review of the camera with more samples and verdicts, I'll come back here and link to their page. In the meantime, as always, I'd suggest that you scour YouTube for some reviews from proper photographers, not me, to gain a more informed opinion!

What a cracking little phone, though. It might just be my new favourite! I'm a sucker for anything Moto, as many people reading this will know. Hopefully that doesn't jade my view and opinion too much. I hope that even through that I can be objective and tell it like it is, not completely through rose-tinted glasses! The Neo line has always held fascination for us here at Phones Show Chat and always seems to offer excellent value-for-money in terms of features and performance. The speakers are usually good, Qi charging included (though they skipped it with last year's 40 Neo sadly), a dinky little size, much like the 30 Neo, great P-OLED screen and this year with HelloUI they've pushed the boat out with an Always on Display, IP6/8 with Military Grade protection and that 5 OS update schedule and long security commitment. I picked this up for £339 but even at full price £399 it feels like a bargain. And, as we know, prices of Moto phones come down pretty quickly as they and their partners get aggressive on pricing to get a Moto into as many hands as possible. As you may have gathered by now, I recommend it enormously!