I'm not sure how it's taken me this long to pluck this one from my collection to watch, especially as I've generally appreciated the work of Guillermo del Toro. This is an atmospheric, lavish gothic romance with horror, gore and ghostly interludes, set in Victorian-era Buffalo, New York, and Cumbria, England.
We start off in Buffalo with young Edith Cushing (Sofia Wells) being briefly visited by the ghost of her recently deceased mother - an encounter that terrifies her, though she manages to shut it out. We then jump 14 years into the future. Edith (now played by Mia Wasikowska) is an aspiring author living with her father, a wealthy, self-made businessman. After all these years, she is suddenly visited once more by her mother’s apparition, who this time warns her not to go to Crimson Peak. It's not until much later in the film that we discover what - and where - that actually is.
This warning coincides with the arrival of a charming English aristocrat, Sir Thomas Sharpe (Tom Hiddleston) and his cold sister Lucille (Jessica Chastain). They have turned up looking for investors for Thomas’s clay-harvesting invention back in England. Lucille is suspicious-looking from the start, but it's clear that the bond between brother and sister is exceptionally strong.
After much socialising, it becomes obvious that Thomas and Edith have fallen for each other. However, her father smells a rat and actively seeks to drive a wedge between them to protect his beloved daughter. So much so, in fact, that he attempts to engineer a situation involving a bribe to end the liaison and send Thomas packing. Just in the nick of time for the prospective couple, Edith's father snuffs it, leaving a grieving Edith to marry Thomas and move to his family estate, Allerdale Hall in Cumbria.
The mansion is a decaying mess with half the roof missing, weather getting in, floorboards rotting and the entire structure sitting on top of a red clay mine. As a snowy winter sets in (remember those?), red clay pushes up through the ground, staining the snow crimson. Crimson Peak - aha! Thomas's sister Lucille lives in the massive family seat as well, though there is plenty of room for them not to be on top of one another. Before long, Edith's health begins to deteriorate and she starts seeing ghosts roaming the corridors of the dark, sinister house once more. This is the point where the reveals start rolling out, so I'll leave the synopsis there.
The film has the feel of a classic 19th-century novel - think Jane Eyre or Wuthering Heights. Del Toro uses ghosts not so much for cheap, nasty scares (though there are a few grisly moments scattered throughout) as metaphors for historical secrets, unresolved grief and deep-seated family trauma. What elevates the production further is how he treats Allerdale Hall as an additional character rather than just a backdrop. Apparently built in a Toronto studio as a fully functional three-story set - complete with working plumbing and real snow falling through the gaping roof - the decay feels real. This attention to detail extends seamlessly to the costume design - Lucille's sharp, rigid black velvet dresses are explicitly tailored to look like a predatory black moth, contrasting sharply with Edith’s fragile, butterfly-like bright yellow gowns. It’s a great bit of attention to detail to aid visual storytelling.
Benedict Cumberbatch was originally cast as Sir Thomas Sharpe, but dropped out due to creative differences and scheduling conflicts, while Emma Stone was slated to play Edith before leaving for La La Land. Hiddleston stepped in with just 72 hours' notice after receiving del Toro's call, and Wasikowska took over. The entire cast does an excellent job transitioning from the leisurely, socialite-driven opening in America to the bloody, high-drama climax. There has to be a grand finale in such a sumptuous gothic romp, of course - especially with del Toro at the helm!
I really enjoyed it. It is admittedly a bit of a slow burn at first, but after the first half-hour of its two-hour run time, it picks up and firmly demands your attention. It's over ten years old as I write this, making it widely accessible across subscription streaming platforms. You probably need to be in the right mood for a slow-paced visual treat (at least in the first acts), but if you are, this is a beautifully crafted piece of fantasy-gothic cinema.













